‘Madden’ Review: David O. Russell’s Latest Is a Total Misfire

Madden is a spectacular misfire that wastes both its fascinating subject and a talented cast.

Madden

David O. Russell’s (Silver Linings Playbook) Madden follows the life and career of legendary American football coach John Madden, from leading the Oakland Raiders to a Super Bowl victory alongside team owner Al Davis, to becoming a celebrated broadcaster and helping develop the Madden NFL video game franchise. Starring Nicolas Cage (Longlegs) as Madden and Christian Bale (The Dark Knight) as Davis, the film attempts to capture the larger-than-life personalities behind one of American football’s most recognisable figures. Unfortunately, it’s a dreadful biopic that relies on hammy performances and a painfully generic storyline, turning what should be an interesting true story into something that feels more like an overinflated SNL skit than a digestible feature film. 

One of Madden’s few redeeming qualities could have been its energy, with O. Russell ensuring the film evokes a fast pace for the majority of its almost two-hour runtime. However, this relentless approach quickly becomes exhausting, leaving little room for the characters or audience to breathe. The film is constantly rushing to the next moment, playing out like a running montage of scenes that rarely string together in a coherent or particularly enjoyable way. The editing only adds to the mess, making the story feel more like a collection of disconnected highlights than a properly constructed biopic. This is accompanied by a constant stream of generic needle drops and an onslaught of on-screen effects and drawings, all fighting for the audience’s attention rather than adding anything meaningful to the story. What might initially seem energetic and lively soon becomes irritating, with the film’s inability to slow down or show any restraint making it a tiring watch by the end. It’s a bafflingly messy piece of filmmaking and, quite possibly, O. Russell’s worst-directed work to date. 

Madden

The film’s biggest problem, however, is its complete lack of focus. Despite John Madden having a fascinating life and career to draw from, Madden struggles to find anything particularly interesting to say about its subject, offering little intrigue throughout. Instead, much of the story gets bogged down in a dull relationship drama between Madden and his wife, Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), which feels generic and adds little to the overall picture of who he was. The plot is full of familiar biopic beats, but there’s nothing fresh or particularly compelling about how they’re handled. It often feels unclear what Russell actually wants the film to be about, with its various threads failing to come together into anything coherent. The humour rarely lands, while the dramatic moments lack the grit, emotional weight or substance needed to give the story any real impact. Even the football scenes disappoint, offering little excitement or tension to engage viewers, whether they’re devoted fans of the sport or not. With so much potential in Madden’s life and achievements, it’s frustrating to watch a film that does so little with them. 

See also  'Longlegs' Review: Procedural Police Thriller meets Harrowing Horror

You’d think a cast like this would be able to salvage a film that’s otherwise such a mess, but the performances aren’t much to write home about either. There’s some mileage in watching Nicolas Cage go completely over the top as Madden, but the novelty wears off quickly, with his awful voice and mannerisms becoming more grating than entertaining. Christian Bale fares little better as Al Davis, delivering a performance that feels surprisingly unremarkable given his usual ability to disappear into a role. Sienna Miller (American Sniper) is largely sidelined, barely given enough material to make an impression, while Kathryn Hahn (Glass Onion) brings some charm and humour to Virginia, only for her character to become trapped in a repetitive arc. It’s difficult to know how much of this falls on the cast and how much on the script they’ve been handed, but the result is underwhelming across the board. Even with such a recognisable line-up, there’s little here to make the characters or their performances particularly memorable. 

Madden is a spectacular misfire that wastes both its fascinating subject and a talented cast. Its relentless energy occasionally keeps things moving, and there are fleeting moments of entertainment in Cage’s larger-than-life portrayal, but neither is enough to make this a worthwhile watch. With little insight into Madden’s life, a muddled story and an approach that mistakes excess for personality, it’s another frustratingly poor effort from O. Russell. What could have been a compelling portrait of an American sporting icon instead feels like an overblown caricature.

Madden
Madden (2026)
1.5

Becca Johnson

Becca is a Rotten Tomato-approved freelance critic from Essex, UK, with a penchant for horror and coming-of-age. She can mainly be found at Film Focus Online, where she is Senior Writer. She specialises in new release reviews, rankings and Top 10's.

LEAVE A REPLY

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

‘Heartland’ Review: Jessica Chastain Shines in an Uneven Nashville Thriller